Volume 2 - issue 2 - 2006

Interactive and face-to-face communication:

a perspective from philosophy of mind and language

Based on experiences from an educational programme for medical paramedics which combines physical gatherings with online activities, Halvor Nordby has developed a framework for both interactive and face-to-face communication. Important questions he addresses are similarities and differences between these two types of communication, and he makes use of modern philosophical hermeneutics in his research. With successful communication as the goal, both descriptive and normative approaches are made. Halvor Nordby is professor at Lillehammer University College and at the University of Oslo.

(The video requires Flash)  

Halvor Nordby
Lillehammer University College
Faculty of Health and Social Research
This email address is being protected from spambots. You need JavaScript enabled to view it.">This email address is being protected from spambots. You need JavaScript enabled to view it.

University of Oslo
Faculty of Medicine
Department of Health Management and Health Economy
This email address is being protected from spambots. You need JavaScript enabled to view it.">This email address is being protected from spambots. You need JavaScript enabled to view it.


The aim of this article is to derive fundamental communication conditions from central assumptions in recent philosophy of mind and language, and then use these conditions to clarify essential similarities and differences between face-to-face and interactive communication. The analyses are to a large extent made on the basis of participant observations and dialogues with students in a further education course for medical paramedics, but the conclusions should be of interest to anyone who has a pedagogical interest in understanding the nature of the two forms of communication. The arguments set out in the article have both a descriptive and a normative dimension. They are descriptive in the sense that they aim to give a philosophical analysis of successful communication; they are normative in the sense that they seek to understand how communication can be improved. The article concludes that the philosophical analysis presented constitutes a plausible conceptual framework for analyzing empirical phenomena related to face-to-face and interactive communication.

1. Introduction

Lecturers, supervisors and other persons with teaching responsibilities in modern education programs are often involved in two forms of communication: face-to-face communication, in which the participants in a communicative process can observe each other and the wider context of communication, and interactive communication, in which communication happens through some interactive communication channel. Dialogues with students in traditional, physical classrooms are typical examples of the first kind of communication; supervision and discussions via internet-based programs like ‘Classfronter’ are typical examples of the second.
It is obvious that both face-to-face and interactive communication can involve fundamental challenges for communicators, but it is not so clear exactly how these challenges should be understood and related to each other. An important theoretical question is therefore this: To what extent are the communicative challenges involved in the two forms of communication similar, and to what extent are they essentially different?

A thorough analysis of all the potentially relevant aspects of this question would require a very comprehensive discussion. The obvious reason is that the question can be discussed from different perspectives, and that it is unreasonable, at least prima facie, to give one of these perspectives conceptual or epistemic priority (Davies 1998, Peacocke 1998). A better suggestion is that the similarities and differences between face-to-face communication and interactive communication can be elucidated in different ways, and that a variety of analyses can jointly contribute to a better, overall understanding of the nature of the two forms of communication.

My primary motivation for exploring the nature of face-to-face and interactive communication has been the need to understand communicative challenges that confront students in a national further education program for medical paramedics. As the person responsible for one of the courses in this program I have, from a pedagogical and theoretical point of view, attempted to analyze the various forms of interaction paramedics are involved in. I have, in particular, sought to address two questions: What are some of the fundamental problems of understanding paramedics confront when they encounter patients and other health personnel in face-to-face situations? How are these problems similar to, but also different from, the challenges they confront when they communicate interactively via radio or telephone with other health personnel such as nurses in acute medical communication centers? 

The aim of this article is to address some important aspects of these questions on the basis of recent philosophical theories of speech acts and concept possession (Guttenplan 1996; Bechtel & Graham 1998). Within the theoretical framework I develop, I make a fundamental distinction between four communication conditions: firstly, speaker and audience (in a wide sense) need to share a common language that can be used to convey and understand a belief. Secondly, the audience must realize that the speaker has the intention of communicating this belief. Thirdly, speaker and audience must not associate beliefs and thoughts that are literally expressed in language with very different sets of other beliefs and thoughts. And finally, the experiences, motives and values that an audience ascribes to a speaker must not be radically different from the experiences, motives and values that a speaker intends to express. 

I will argue that this philosophical framework is completely general but also particularistic. That is, the four conditions can be used to show how face-to-face and interactive communication involve some of the same fundamental communicative processes, but the conditions can also be used to illuminate crucial differences. This fact, I will argue, constitutes a plausible argument for using the conditions as a conceptual framework for analyzing empirical phenomena related to the two forms of communication. Moreover, the fact that the framework is suitable for understanding and explaining the two forms of communication constitutes an independent justification for the framework itself, as a genuine theory of communication. 
In the last part of the article, I examine the question of how it is possible to avoid various forms of misunderstanding that occur when one or several of the four communication conditions are not met. This discussion is to a large extent based on ideas that have been central within modern philosophical hermeneutics (Bleicher 1980; Mueller-Vollmer 1986; Smith 1997). I focus particularly on Gadamer’s (1975) idea of the aim of understanding as a ‘fusion of horizons’ and argue that in order to avoid poor communication, it is imperative that speakers are aware of various intrinsic aspects of the cognitive and emotional perspectives audiences have. I conclude that this and other implications of the arguments I present should be of interest to anyone who wants to acquire a more philosophical understanding of the nature of face-to-face and interactive communication.

2. Background

’Nasjonal Paramedic Utdanning’ (http://paramedic.hil.no/) is a national further education course for health personnel working as paramedics in the national health services in Norway. The program consists of six courses, four of which focus mainly on issues directly related to medicine, one on legal issues and one on communication and ethics.

The need for focusing on communication in the program is obvious. In their daily work as paramedics the students are to a large extent involved in interpersonal relations where empathy, understanding and dialogue are important factors for securing successful interaction. With respect to the especially important relation between paramedics and patients, it is crucial that paramedics are able to understand adequately how patients experience and think about their states of disease, illness or sickness. Their choice of verbal and non-verbal behavior must be based on justified beliefs about the emotional and cognitive perspectives patients have on their condition of disease or illness (Enelow, Forde & Brummel-Smith 1996, Nordby 2004a; Nordby 2006).

A detailed analysis of the diversity of communicative contexts paramedics face in interaction with patients and other health personnel falls outside the scope of this article. The important point I will focus on is that paramedics are involved in two forms of communication that are essentially different from each other. Firstly, they are involved in many direct, face-to-face encounters with patients, relatives of patients and other health personnel - situations in which they are able to observe not only the persons they communicate with but also the wider context of communication. When communicators are able to observe each other in this way, the obvious consequence is that it is possible to use more than uttered words as interpretative clues. Interpretation can also be made on the basis of non-verbal behavior and other observable aspects of the communicative context (Nordby 2004b). The significance of this consequence is obvious. Normally, when we seek to understand other persons we rely on literal interpretation. As Burge (1979, p.88) observes, “literal interpretation is ceteris paribus preferred” in ordinary discourse. For instance, if a speaker says ‘It is raining’, audiences normally assume that the speaker, as long as he means to be sincere, expresses the belief that it is raining involving the concepts it, is and raining that are literally expressed by the words he utters.

The qualification ‘normally’ is important. Sometimes certain aspects of a situation constitute good reason for being skeptical about literal interpretation, as in the case of incongruent communication involving a definite mismatch between verbal and non-verbal behavior. By being sensitive to the potential importance of non-verbal interpretative clues, communicators can avoid incongruent communication and other forms of poor communication that can occur when there is a mismatch between what is strictly speaking said and what is more generally displayed (Eide & Eide 2004). In such cases of experienced inconsistency, attentive audiences use the wider context to form special non-literal and complex interpretations that do not correspond directly to the words that a speaker utters (Davidson 1984). Furthermore, it is a widespread view that there are no observable aspects of face-to-face communicative contexts that are irrelevant in principle for determining the non-literal meaning of verbal speech acts (Bezuidenhout 1997; Cappelen & Lepore 2005). Face-to-face interpretation is essentially holistic; interpreters’ beliefs about the meaning of speakers’ utterances are based on assumptions about of all sorts of observations and all sorts of assumptions about speakers’ social and cultural contexts.  

Face-to-face communication has received most attention in the health care literature focusing on interaction between health personnel and patients, but interactive communication - here defined as communication that does not involve a face-to-face encounter - is often equally important for paramedics (Tjora 1997). When an ambulance is called out, it has received an interactive appeal from an Acute Medical Communication center (AMC - center) where emergency nurses who cooperate with ambulance coordinators have answered an emergency call (‘113’ in Norway). This interactive appeal has several elements, including a precise a description as possible of where the patient is, a categorization of the acuteness of the assignment according to a code, and an indication of the nature of the patient’s state of injury, illness or disease.1   

Furthermore, while patients are being transported there is often extensive interactive dialogue between paramedics and the AMC-center. The paramedics often provide information about the patient’s state of illness or disease, they sometimes ask for medical supervision, and they sometimes require further back-up assistance from other medical units. There are, in fact, a wide range of aspects related to patients’ conditions that are of potential significance in this interactive communication. From the perspectives of all the parties involved, the experienced success of the paramedic-patient interaction will often depend heavily on adequate interactive communication.

It should already now be emphasized that when I distinguish between face-to-face communication and interactive communication in this way, I do not mean to argue that the two types of communication involve communicative processes that are different in principle. On the contrary, I believe that the assumptions I make are consistent with the plausible view that communication is a contextual, interpretative process, and that the difference between face-to-face and interactive communication fundamentally is a difference of degree. The reason this is an important point to make is that some might infer from the above that I rely on unjustified assumptions about some underlying principled distinction, but this is not the case. All I am presupposing is that we have a reasonable clear idea of what the differences between face-to-face and interactive communication are.

More could be said about face-to-face and interactive communication and the particular ways in which paramedics are involved in these forms of communication, but this would fall outside the limits of this article. For my present argumentative purposes, it is sufficient to clarify the basic nature of two forms of communication. I assume, in particular, that I have made it clear that face-to-face communication and interactive communication must involve some different communicative challenges. In the following, I will first develop fundamental communication conditions that are relevant for understanding communication in general, and then use these conditions to shed light on relevant differences.

3. Philosophical perspective

In trying to understand some of the fundamental communicative challenges that paramedics confront in their daily work as health personnel, it has been important to make extensive observation studies in ambulances and AMC-centers. These studies have given me valuable knowledge of how the students in the further education course experience and try to solve problems of communication. At the same time it is important to remember that although observations of human behavior and interaction must necessarily provide the basis for deciding whether communication succeeds or fails in a given context, such observations alone cannot establish whether communication succeeds. Conclusions about the status of a communicative process must always be made on the basis of assumptions about the nature of communication. Traditionally, these assumptions have focused on how the ‘external’ - behavior and context – must match the ‘inner’ - the subjective and private (Davidson 1984, Bezuidenhout 1997; Cappelen & Lepore 2005). The traditional idea has been that a speaker has successfully communicated an ‘inner’ mental state S to an audience if, and only if, the audience understands that the speaker intends to use verbal or non-verbal actions to convey state S to him.

Of course, making such communicative assumptions is something we do more or less unconsciously all the time in ordinary discourse, and even if the aim is nothing more than to explicate our common everyday assumptions, we have in effect started to clarify a theory of communication. Indeed, the difference between common sense theories of communication and the philosophical perspective I will apply here is not meant to be one of principle. The aim is rather to locate assumptions that (a) appeal to our ordinary ideas and (b) can be used to understand the fundamental challenges that face-to-face and interactive communication involve.
The theoretical framework I will use in seeking to achieve this twofold aim is grounded in a modern tradition within cognitive science and philosophy of mind and language (Guttenplan 1996; Bechtel & Graham 1998). According to theories that fall within this tradition, verbal and non-verbal actions are conceived of as intentional language acts that express beliefs and thoughts. Beliefs and thoughts are in turn thought of as psychological attitudes to propositions involving mental concepts (Burge 1979; Peacocke 1992). For instance, the sentence ‘Water quenches thirst’ is normally used to express the belief that water quenches thirst involving the three concepts water, quenches and thirst. When a speaker associates these concepts with the sentence, communication of the concepts has succeeded if, and only if, the audience understands that the speaker intends to communicate a belief involving these concepts.
It should be emphasized that this does not mean that an audience must necessarily think that is it correct to understand a language act in the same way as a speaker. For communicative purposes, all that is required is that the belief that an audience thinks that a speaker intends to communicate really is the belief the speaker intends to communicate. Questions about the objective and normative status of the meaning of language acts are therefore not directly relevant for questions of communication; whether communication happens must be determined on the basis of considerations of how speaker and audience understand each other, not on the basis of considerations of how it is correct to understand a given language (Nordby 2006). 2

This point is of particular importance in discourse involving disputed concepts with unclear application conditions, like the basic health concepts disease, illness and sickness (Mechanic 1968; Nettleton 1995; Worhall & Worhall 2003). Health professionals sometimes encounter patients who do not understand these concepts in ways that correspond to influential conceptions within the health services, but if a paramedic tries to adopt a patient’s understanding for communicative purposes, exchange of concepts can happen even if the patient’s understanding is regarded as controversial or even incorrect.
A second and more philosophical point that should be made about the framework of communication that I will use, is that I do not mean to argue that it constitutes the only possible way of analyzing communication. Basically, what I am relying on is that the framework represents a fundamental and influential way of understanding human interaction. I presuppose, in particular, that the assumption that successful communication involves successful exchange of subjective states has an intuitive, immediate appeal that is grounded in our ordinary communicative practices. Of course, in everyday communication it is not common to think of exchange of thoughts and other subjective states as communicative processes, but the reason why the assumption is plausible is not that it aims to capture a process that we are consciously aware of in ordinary discourse. The reason is rather that as long as we conceive of communication as a rational activity, then we have to think of understanding and communication in cognitive terms: our understanding of the language we use, and the way we try to communicate our concepts to others, cannot be reduced to observable behaviour. As McDowell notes,

...to learn the meaning of a word is to acquire an understanding that obliges us subsequently – if we have occasion to deploy the concept in question – to judge and speak in certain determinate ways, on pain of failure to obey the dictates of the meaning we have grasped” (McDowell 1994, p. 160).

McDowell’s claim is illuminating, not only because it is reasonable in itself, but also because McDowell ascribes it to the later Wittgenstein. In contrast to the tradition that McDowell’s interpretation of Wittgenstein is framed within, Wittgenstein is sometimes described as a modified behaviorist. According to this behaviorist interpretation, communication is essentially an observable activity within ‘language-games’, an activity that can be fully explained by referring to how we conform to language rules in different contexts (Kripke 1982).

Whether or not it is (contrary to what McDowell thinks) correct to ascribe some kind of behaviorist ‘third person’ perspective to Wittgenstein, is an important question of exegesis, but it would fall outside the scope of this article to address it. For the purposes here it is more important to think of behaviorism as a genuine source of challenge to cognitive analyses of communication. Independently of what Wittgenstein writes, some might argue that all versions of behaviorism are not obviously false, and that I have not showed why the cognitive framework of communication I have adopted here is more plausible than all these versions.  

Is important to say something briefly about this objection, first and foremost because the choice of framework has substantial different practical consequences. Consider as an example a patient who utters the sentence ‘I am in pain’ and a paramedic who comes to assistance. A behaviorist will typically think of this as a complete communicative process and claim that further explanations that refer to ‘underlying’ subjective states and audiences’ mental interpretations of these states are irrelevant, superfluous or ‘quasi’ explanations that fall outside the realm of proper psychological explanations. 3

There are in my opinion two main problems with this view. Firstly, and as indicated above, if McDowell is correct, then it is possible to think that the way we understand words and communicate meaning is derived from our use of language, and at the same time think that explanations of underlying mental phenomena are important. According to McDowell, what Wittgenstein is opposed to is not mental explanations per se, but a certain way of conceiving of the relation between ‘private’ subjective states and observable actions. It is only if one starts out with a classical Cartesian first-person perspective that one is easily led to think that this dualism involves overwhelmingly difficult epistemic and metaphysical obstacles (Burge 1979; Nordby 2004c). The problem with behaviorism as a response to the Cartesian tradition is that the position inherits the same dualistic way of thinking. The only difference is that behaviorism starts from the other end - from the ‘outside’ - and then claims that it is only this perspective that we have ‘real’ epistemic access to. Behaviorism is a general doctrine that is grounded in a positivistic idea of what counts as elements in scientific explanations of communication.

Secondly, objections to the scientific status of cognitive analyses of communication often seem to rest on the idea that there is only one ‘proper’ level of psychological explanation. However, there is no good reason for holding that this is so. It is true that it is possible, on one level, to explain communication from a third-person perspective. And from this perspective it is correct to say that communication has succeeded if an audience manifests appropriate behavior as a response to actions performed by a speaker. But accepting that this is correct is compatible with holding that there is more to say about underlying mental processes from other perspectives. 

Consider again the above example of a patient who utters ‘I am in pain’ and a paramedic who comes to assistance. How are we to understand this as a communicative process? We find it overwhelmingly natural to assume that the patient really is in pain (as long as he is sincere), that his utterance expresses his experience of being in pain, and that he intends the paramedic to understand that he is in pain (as long as his utterance is not merely an expression of pain) and so on. It is equally natural to assume that the reason the paramedic comes to assistance is that he thinks that the patient is in pain. This idea about the patient’s state of illness is derived from the fact that the patient used the sentence he used, and probably other interpretative clues like signs of pain. In short, the paramedic forms a belief about the patient’s state of mind on the basis of observable properties of the context. Again, this does not depend on a special Cartesian picture of the mental, or on the idea that interpretation is a conscious process. It is simply a natural way of widening a more narrow third-person explanation of what communication involves.

Hopefully, this defense of the plausibility of the cognitive framework has indicated why it has a strong appeal, and why proponents of other approaches therefore face formidable challenges. Obviously, much more could be said about communication as a fundamental philosophical concept, but that would fall outside the aim here as long as my main focus is the application of the framework within health care. In the next section I will argue that theories of speech acts and concept possession can potentially shed theoretically interesting light on face-to-face and interactive communication, and that they can be used to analyze crucial differences within a completely general framework. I have explained how the framework focuses in a comprehensive way on verbal and non-verbal speech acts, but I have also indicated how it implies that an observable context can play a crucial role in interpretation. In the following I will first focus on the issue of general significance and then discuss the idea of an observable context in more detail.

4. Communication conditions

Clarifying how communication can succeed or fail is equivalent to clarifying communication conditions – conditions that must be met in order for successful communication to happen. In order to understand communicative challenges within the framework I have outlined, I will make a fundamental distinction between four conditions. The first is that communication requires a common language:
(i) In order for an audience to understand a speaker, it is necessary that they share a platform of shared concepts.
Here I use the expression ‘speaker’ in a wide sense to mean someone who has a belief, thought or other concept-involving psychological attitude that he wishes to communicate to an audience (one or several persons). Since audiences are unable to grasp speakers’ thoughts and beliefs directly, these subjective states have to be expressed in language acts that can be seen, heard or observed and interpreted in other ways. As emphasized above, this can be all sorts of intentional behavior, but for the sake of clarity I will in the following primarily focus on verbal speech acts. Thus, in order for an audience to be able to understand that a speaker expresses a given belief, it is necessary that the speaker and the audience understand the sentence that the speaker uses in a sufficiently similar way, so that they associate the same concepts with the words that the speaker uses (Cappelen & Lepore 2005).
The qualification ‘sufficiently similar’ is important. When I claim that speaker and audience must have a common language, I do not mean that they have to understand this language in the same way in the sense that they use it in exactly the same ‘language games’ (Wittgenstein 1953). It is sufficient that their understanding is so similar that that they associate the words that are used with the same concepts (Burge 1979; Peacocke 1992; Guttenplan 1996).
This, in effect, presupposes that the conditions for the sharing of concepts are weaker than the conditions for sameness of understanding. It is obvious that communicators must have some similar understanding of a word in order to associate the same concept with it – the understanding that the audience has must to some extent approximate the speaker’s understanding.4 But this leaves open what a sufficiently similar understanding is, and exactly what the threshold condition for shared concepts is has been a disputed issue (for a discussion of this, see Nordby 2004c).

I will not presuppose any specific view on this issue here, but I will rely on the widespread idea that it is unnecessary that communicators use a word in exactly the same way in order to associate the same concept with it. The main reason why this idea is reasonable is this: We very seldom use language in exactly the same ways; there are normally differences due to our respective social and cultural contexts. So if we needed an identical understanding in order to share concepts, we would, in fact, seldom be able to exchange beliefs and thoughts involving the same concepts. Furthermore, laypersons should not need complete expert competence regarding the application conditions of a term in order to express the same concept as persons who have expert competence (Putnam 1981; Pessin & Goldberg 1996). If that were the case, laypersons within a given area of discourse would be unable to communicate with experts (consider again the area of health care and the relation between patients and medical doctors). This is a counterintuitive consequence, and it constitutes a good reason for being skeptical about the view that a platform of shared concepts requires an identical understanding.
The second communication condition I wish to focus on is more straightforward:
(ii) In order for a speaker to be able to communicate a belief, he needs to have the attention of the audience.
The idea is as follows: A speaker might express a belief, used a language that the speaker and the audience have a sufficiently similar understanding of and think it has reached the consciousness of the audience. It can nevertheless happen that the audience fails to realize that the speaker intends to communicate this belief. The reason for this may be lack of attention, problems of interpretation due to a chaotic situation, or an impaired capacity for rational reasoning (a patient might be in a state of shock or under the influence of drugs). But the problem may also be of a more technological nature, e.g. computers that do not work so that audiences are unable to use them as interactive communication tools.

It is important to bear in mind that in order for a misunderstanding of this kind to occur, the speaker must be unaware of the communicative problems. The speaker must genuinely believe that he has the attention of the audience, that there is no significant communicative ‘noise’ or disruption; otherwise he would not be sincerely attempting to communicate a belief. An example can be used to illustrate the point:

Paramedics encounter a patient who has taken a large amount of paracetamol. Relatives have called 113, and the patient himself, in a confused and agitated state, makes it clear that he does not want to be taken to hospital. In order to persuade the patient that treatment in hospital is necessary, the paramedics try to inform the patient about the physiological effects of paracetamol and they tell him that large doses of paracetamol can lead to serious irreversible damage to the liver. They hope that this information will lead the patient to change his mind, but this does not happen. Consequently, the paramedics decide that there is little use in trying to persuade the patient, and they begin to consider more complicated strategies for securing necessary transport and treatment. 
In this situation it was evident that the paramedics assumed that the information about the negative health effects of large doses of paracetamol had reached the consciousness of the patient. However, it soon became evident that this had not happened. When the patient calmed down and his relatives told him what the paramedics had said, the patient realized the gravity of the situation and made it clear that he wanted to go to the hospital after all. In the first place, because of his confused state and the stressful encounter with the paramedics, the patient did not form the belief that the paramedics intended to communicate and thought that it was important to communicate.
If we manage to avoid the two forms of misunderstands that occur when conditions (i) or (ii) are not met, does this mean that communication has succeeded? Not necessarily. Even if speaker and audience have a platform of shared concepts, and even if the speaker has the attention of the audience so that the message that he intends to communicate actually reaches the consciousness of the audience, it might still happen that the audience associates this message with beliefs and thoughts that are very different from the set of beliefs and thoughts that the speaker associates with the message. This third form of misunderstanding corresponds to a third communication condition:
(iii) The wider set of beliefs and thoughts that an audience associates with a belief that is directly expressed in language must not be radically different from the wider set of beliefs and thoughts that the speaker associates with this belief.

As Davidson (1987, p.449) notes, interpretation always “rests on vague assumptions about what is and what is not shared” by speaker and audience, and problems typically arise when assumptions about what is shared beliefs turn out to be incorrect. Of course, if communicators’ perspectives are so radically different that they influence the semantic interpretation of the language that a speaker uses, then the misunderstanding that arises is a misunderstanding of the first kind (i). In such cases speaker and audience do not even have a common language. A misunderstanding of the third kind requires that the message that is literally expressed by language is understood, that the communicators have a sufficiently similar understanding of the words that are used in the sense explained above. The problem that can still arise is that the beliefs that surround this message are radically different. An example can illustrate the point:

An AMC-nurse tells a patient who has called 113 that ‘The ambulance is on its way’. The patient forms the belief that the ambulance is on its way, but he then forms a further belief - the belief that the ambulance will arrive very soon within the next few minutes. The patient expresses disappointment when the ambulance arrives after 30 minutes.

In this case communication of the belief that the ambulance is on its way has succeeded. The AMC-nurse has the attention of the patient, and they both associate the concepts the, ambulance, is, on, its and way with the sentence ‘The ambulance is on its way’. The problem is that communication has failed in the wider sense that the AMC-nurse does not associate the belief that the ambulance is on its way with the belief that the ambulance will arrive within a few minutes.5 The patient, however, forms this association. He grasps the content of the message that the nurse expresses literally in words, but he then forms further associations that are radically different from the way the nurse intends this message to be understood.

The qualification ‘radically different’ is important here. Two persons never associate the beliefs and thoughts they form with other beliefs and thoughts in exactly the same way; there will always be some different associations as long as interpretation is shaped by social and cultural context (Burge 1979; Davidson 1984; Smith 1997). The important point is that there are many cases in which the associations that are formed are so different that poor communication occurs. From the perspectives of speakers, it is the beliefs that it is most important to communicate that are ordinarily expressed literally in words; that is why communication of these beliefs is normally straightforward. It is when speaker and audience understand what is not strictly speaking said in significantly different ways, that a misunderstanding of the third kind (iii) occurs.

Is communication ensured if we manage to avoid the three forms of misunderstanding that correspond to communication conditions (i)-(iii)? We might think so, but this is because we sometimes tend to forget that communication is not always a rational activity. In addition to beliefs and thoughts that are true or false, there are many other subjective states that are important in human interaction. The fourth and final communication condition is meant to capture the fact that we sometimes communicate psychological states that are essentially different from beliefs and thought that are true or false:
(iv) The values, emotions and other non-conceptual subjective states that an audience ascribes to a speaker must not be different from the values, emotions and other non-conceptual states that the speaker intends to communicate. 
 By ‘values, emotions and other non-conceptual subjective states’ I mean states that cannot be ascribed as beliefs or thoughts that involve concepts. When we think about communication we often tend to focus on such states, on attitudes we ascribe by saying things like ‘S believes that p’ or ‘S thinks that p’ where ‘p’ is a concept-involving proposition. For instance, when I say ‘S believes that snow is white’, I ascribe to S the attitude of believing in a proposition involving the three concepts snow, is and white (which is true if snow is white and otherwise false). It is easy to forget that we sometimes intend to communicate psychological states that are not attitudes to propositions. Personal values are not attitudes to propositions, it makes no grammatical sense to say ‘S values that p’ and replace for ‘p’ propositions that are true or false depending on how the world is. Personal values are rather attitudes to ‘forms of living’ (Wittgenstein 1953; Johnston 1989); to the ways we wish to live our lives and the activities we like to participate in (Dancy 1996). The same applies to emotions and other personal experiences. The way I feel a certain pain, or the way I have a visual impression of a computer in front of me, cannot be directly experienced by another person. I can attempt to report and communicate my experience by using a sentence that I think is true or false (‘I am in pain’, ‘I have the impression of seeing a computer in front of me’), but this sentence is not identical to the state I talk about and have privileged first-person access to. The state is a pure subjective experience, not a belief or thought about something (Rosenthal 1991).
Understood in this way, the significance of (iv) becomes similar to that of (iii). We often try to communicate our personal values and experiences to other persons, but sometimes our audiences ascribe to us states that are different from those we intend to communicate. For instance, a patient who uses emotional vocabulary like ‘I am in pain’ will normally be interpreted as expressing a state with a certain qualitative ‘pain’ content. If this interpretation is wrong - if the pain that the paramedic thinks that the patient feels is very different from the qualitative nature of the pain the patient feels – then a misunderstanding of the fourth kind has occurred.

Values that are attitudes to forms of life or activities are subject to the same problems of interpretation. In discourse between persons from different social or cultural contexts the values that are ascribed may be different from the values that the communicators have. It is reasonable to assume that this sometimes occurs in paramedic-patient interaction. A patient who is perceived as a person who appreciates that the paramedics are acting in a certain way might in fact be a patient who endorses an alternative course of action. Typical cases include interaction between elderly people and younger paramedics who have a more ‘modern’ way of life. In one case observed by the author of this paper, a paramedic consequently addressed an elderly patient by his first name, even though it was fairly evident that the patient would have appreciated an alternative course of action (e.g. he introduced himself using his surname).

This last communication condition (iv) might seem to inflate the philosophical framework of speech acts and concepts, but this is not the case. On the contrary, since the first three conditions focus entirely on concept-involving beliefs and thoughts, it is possible to formulate a fourth condition that captures the remaining ‘subjective’ and qualitative dimension of human communication. The philosophical framework I have outlined leaves room for this further condition precisely because it makes a sharp distinction between concept-involving and non-concept-involving subjective states.

5. Implications: interactive and face-to-face communication

I am not going to argue that the four conditions I have presented represent the only possible way of analyzing communication. Holding that they are reasonable is consistent with holding that there are other conditions that are important as well. In fact, I do not even mean to provide a direct argument for the view that the conditions offer a plausible analysis of how poor communication can occur. What I primarily wish to focus on is their explanatory power, particularly the way they can be used to shed light on the similarities and differences between face-to-face and interactive communication.
If we start with the first condition (i), i.e. having a common language, how is this condition relevant for understanding the nature of the two forms of communication? The basic distinction to be made in connection with (i) is that between what a word means and what a speaker means. An utterance heard on the phone or a sentence read on a computer screen means something – it has a semantic content. But when an audience is confronted with a speaker the immediate question for the audience is as follows: What is the mental state – belief, thought or value - that the speaker has and intends to communicate?
This difference of focus corresponds to two different ways of conceiving of a speech act. The activity that is performed interactively is a pure language act; the social context of the act is not part of the meaning of the act. From the perspective of an audience, the aim is to understand the proposition expressed by the language shared by the speaker and the audience. The focus must be explicitly or implicitly on meaning, and the relevant interpretative activities correspond to the scope of philosophy of language – to philosophical questions about the meaning of language.

Face-to-face communication, on the other hand, is a social activity that essentially belongs within pragmatics and philosophy of mind. The question that confronts face-to-face communicators is this: What is the belief that the speaker in this context uses language to express? This is not a semantic question about the meaning of the words per se, but a question about the psychological nature of the relevant mental states of the speaker. 
Even though the interpretative activities involved in the two forms of communication in this way correspond to different philosophical disciplines, it is important to recognize that the activities are similar in the sense that they both involve literal interpretation. That is, we normally assume that words that are used literally express the concepts communicated. We assume, for instance, that the word ‘dog’ in interactive communication means dog, just as we assume that a speaker who uses the word ‘dog’ expresses a belief involving the concept dog. In this sense there is an important similarity between face-to-face and interactive communication, and the requirement that communicators need to have a common language can be used to understand challenges related to concept communication within both forms of communication.

At the same time it is important to bear in mind that there are sometimes good reasons for not accepting literal interpretations, and in such cases the differences between face-to-face and interaction communication become more significant. In order to show why this is so it is important to distinguish three kinds of expressions. The first is what might be considered words with vague or unclear application conditions. Many words that are used in everyday discourse do not have precise definitions, and the meaning explanations speakers give often differ even though they are members of the same linguistic community (Burge 1979; 1986).6  Three of the most disputed words in the area of health care are ‘disease’, ‘illness’ and ‘sickness’ (Lupton 1994; Radley 1994; Worhall and Worhall 2001), but the point is of course general. There are countless vague or abstract words that communicators tend to understand in significantly different ways.

The fact that we commonly use vague words has an important consequence: different conceptions of what words mean are normally easier to detect face-to-face than interactively. There are at least three reasons why this is the case. Firstly, face-to-face communication more often than interactive communication involves substantial dialogue over time in which communicators realize that they do not have a similar understanding. Furthermore, when differences emerge and receive attention, audiences who are interested in communicating tend to adjust their conceptions of what speakers mean. Secondly, it is sometimes evident from the body language or verbal behavior of a person that he does not share the understanding of another person. If a doctor tells a patient who is feeling ill that it has not been establish that he has a disease, and if the patient thinks that the doctor has a very narrow, rigid understanding of ‘disease’, the patient’s body language may manifest incongruent communication: even though the patient says that he accepts the doctor’s opinion, the patient’s body language or other aspects of the communicative context indicate that he disagree. Thirdly, in face-to-face communication speakers have time, and it is often natural, to explicate in some detail how they understand words they conceive of as controversial. In particular, speakers often provide direct or indirect meaning explanations of words they think the audience has an incomplete understanding of.

Again, these points must be understood as prima facie principles that do not cover all cases. For instance, speakers regularly provide meaning explanations in interactive communication, consider an explanation of what an ‘essay’ is that a teacher distributes to his students via the internet. And face-to-face communication does not always involve extensive rational dialogue and proper explanations of theoretical or technical terms that are conceived to be important, as the above ‘paracetamol case’ clearly illustrates. However, it is surely the rule and not the exception that it is easier to detect and influence different conceptions of what a word means in face-to-face communication than in interactive communication.

This also applies to a second kind of words that can be termed ‘qualitative words’. Qualitative words are words that refer to private, individual experiences, or subjective states that have a significant personal element. Typical examples are words that denote states like pain, nausea or dizziness, but the category, as I understand it here, also includes emotional vocabulary like ‘love’, ‘compassion’ and ‘empathy’ that are used to communicate states that do not so clearly refer to determinate conscious experiences. The important point is that these words also have a subjective, private dimension that it can be difficult to detect in communication.  

Communicative challenges related to the use of qualitative words are to a large extent similar to the challenges related to unclear words, but qualitative words have an additional dimension: an audience has by definition only indirect access to a speaker’s first-person experiences, but it is these experiences that constitute the reference and thereby the individual meaning of qualitative words. Qualitative words report these experiences, but they can only function as interpretative clues to the underlying nature of the experiences. This does not necessarily mean that the experiences are completely hidden from an audience; there are few modern traditions in philosophy of mind that hold that emotional states are fully independent from behavior (Rosenthal 1991; Davies 1995; Guttenplan 1996). The important point is that there must be some independence; there are not many theorists today who accept the extreme and classical behaviorist doctrine that experiences are identical to behavior (Ryle 1949). And if we accept the modern, more modest view that experiences are partly displayed in behavior, then it is reasonable to assume that communication of qualitative words more often succeeds in face-to face communication than in interactive communication. Normally, facial expressions or other forms of observable body language constitute part of the content of the experiences that a speaker intends to communicate.
The third category of words that deserve attention is technical or theoretical words. In face-to-face encounters it is sometimes sufficient to watch a person’s eyes in order to discern whether theoretical vocabulary represents meaningless sounds or not. Furthermore, in face-to-face interaction it is possible to use various forms of body language as specialized communicative tools. A good example is the non-verbal dialogue in AMC centers between nurses and ambulance coordinators. While talking to patients on the phone, they are able to observe each other and use body language – language that patients do not observe  – as part of the basis for deciding what to do. An ambulance coordinator might for instance hold up two fingers to suggest to the nurse that the ambulance should be called out under ‘code 2’. If the nurse nods while the patient is on the line, the ambulance coordinator normally proceeds to call up an ambulance under ‘code 2’.

There is also a further aspect of the communication of technical words that is essentially different from the communication of unclear words and experiences. The fact that technical words have a standard, normative meaning means that it is possible to make a principled distinction between experts who have a complete, correct understanding and laypeople who have an incomplete understanding. Within recent philosophy of mind, it has been a widespread view that if a layperson is willing to defer to an expert’s correct understanding of a word, then he possesses the same concept as the expert even though he does not have a complete understanding. Burge expresses this view in an illuminating way when he writes that 
…wherever the subject has attained a certain competence in large relevant parts of his language and has assumed a certain general commitment or responsibility to the communal conventions governing the language’s symbols, the expressions the subject uses take on a certain inertia in determining attributions of mental content to him. (Burge 1979, p. 114)
It is only when a person with an incomplete understanding is unwilling to defer to the normative meaning of a word that he should be understood as someone who has chosen to associate the word with his own individual concept that does not correspond to the correct, normative understanding. Deference-willingness is in this sense a precommunicative attitude: laypeople need to have this attitude in the first place in order to be able to possess the same concepts as experts who possess and fully understand the correct, standard concept.
The fact that this point is valid only when the expert-layperson distinction applies has an important implication: from the perspective of a speaker who has a competent understanding, it is often easier to secure a platform of shared concepts by using words with precise application conditions than by using unclear, everyday words that do not have standard, normative definitions. The reason is that audiences normally think they are entitled to understand the latter words in special, idiosyncratic ways if there is no profession that knows what the correct understanding is (Helman 1984; Lupton 1994). More generally, communicators tend to think that they are justified in understanding and using unclear or vague expressions in accordance with how they have learned them in their particular social and cultural contexts, even though they know that other speakers sometimes use them in other ways in other contexts. In such cases the idea of deference-willingness does not apply: Communicators from different contexts will stand face to face and be unwilling to revise their understanding.7 But when one of the parties is perceived as being an expert on the application of a word within a given area – e.g. the way students often think of their teachers - the non-expert will normally defer and thereby possess the same concept as the expert.

If one seeks to apply this theory of deference-willingness, the strategy will obviously work only if it is possible to give the audience a sufficient understanding and if the audience is really willing to defer. The latter condition is particularly important. Even if there are standard application conditions for a term, this does not help if the audience thinks of the speaker as a strict authority and consequently does not defer to his explanations. From the perspective of a speaker with a competent understanding who faces an audience who does not have a complete understanding, it is therefore necessary to create a situation where the audience feels comfortable deferring to the normative meaning in order to secure a platform of shared concepts. Furthermore, it is reasonable to assume that this aim is easier to achieve face-to-face than interactively. Often a simple smile, a friendly gesture or other form of body language is sufficient for creating an atmosphere in which audiences think of speakers not only as experts, but as sympathetic experts. In this deep philosophical sense, it is easier to secure communication of concepts in face-to-face relations than in interactive relations.

6. Further implications

So far I have focused on implications of the first communication condition (i), but as emphasized above, meeting (i) can only be a necessary condition for meeting the three further conditions (ii)-(iv). When I claim that two persons must understand a language in the same way, what I mean is that they must understand it in the same way in general. Obviously, when a speaker does not have the attention of an audience, speaker and audience do not understand the language act that is performed in the same way there and then. What the second communication condition (ii) was meant to capture is the idea that in order for the communication of a belief to succeed, the attention of the audience is needed in addition to a shared platform of concepts. 
Is (ii) a condition that is relevant in both face-to-face and interactive communication in the way (i) is? It is since speakers always need the attention of their audience in order to be able to communicate beliefs and thoughts. The differences between the two forms of communication do not matter; (ii) represents a fundamental communicative aim both in face-to-face and in interactive communication.

At the same time there is an obvious difference between face-to-face and interactive communication: it is much easier to secure the attention of an audience in the former than in the latter. After all, speakers are normally able to see whether they have the attention of their audience, and it is also easier for them to understand how to proceed in order to secure attention. Again, this does not apply without exception. Audiences might ostensibly understand and internalize what a speaker says but nevertheless make it clear later that they have not formed the beliefs that speakers intend to communicate. Causes can be states of shock or stress but also, less dramatically, lack of genuine attention or problems of concentration.

It is equally evident that the third communication condition that focused on associate misunderstandings applies in both face-to-face and interactive communication. Both forms of communication can involve audiences who associate a message with beliefs and thoughts that are radically different from the beliefs and thoughts that a speaker has. Whether or not the communicators observe each other is not crucial for this. An audience who hears a speaker over the phone might ascribe to the speaker beliefs that the speaker does not have, even though the audience understands what is literally expressed by the sentence in question, as the above ‘The ambulance is on its way’ case clearly illustrated. But this case could also be redescribed to show how a similar misunderstanding could occur face-to-face.  Imagine for instance a doctor who tells a patient who has been hospitalized for some time that ‘Your condition has really improved’. The patient takes this to mean that the doctor thinks that he will be able to leave the hospital within a few days, he becomes frustrated when this turn out to not happen, and we might even imagine that he tells relatives that the doctor gave him false expectations. The problem, we may assume, is that doctor does not associate the belief that the patient’s condition has improved with the belief that the patient should be sent home within a few days. He does not mean to commit himself to this or any other specific interpretation of ‘improved condition’.8

Even though these two cases clearly show that associate misunderstandings can occur both in face-to-face and interactive interaction, they also suggest an argument for the view that they more often occur in the former than the latter. When doctors in situations like the above utter sentences like ‘Your condition has really improved’, it is not unusual for patients to ask ‘Does this mean that I will be able to go home soon?’ if they are concerned about this. There is typically more of an atmosphere of dialogue and conversation in face-to-face communication, and this often causes audiences to clarify their own perspectives and make inquires about the speaker’s beliefs. In fact, communicators’ overall communicative aim is often to clarify their own perspectives and the perspectives of the persons they are talking to. Associate misunderstandings typically occur when the situation is hectic, or when there is for some other reason poor dialogue about different aspects of the issue of discourse. In interactive communication, the problem is often that it takes a lot of time to clarify one’s own perspective extensively.

The same point applies in connection with the last communication condition (iv), which focused on incorrect ascriptions of experiences and values, but now communicators face an additional challenge that makes observation even more significant. On the phone or via radio a person’s subjective states can only be presented as descriptions or single words that express these states. Everything depends on the interpretation that the audience makes; the language that is heard on the phone or seen on the screen is the only interpretative clue. An observable communicative context, on the other hand, will often provide vital clues to the nature of an underlying experience. An adequate understanding of a pain state will normally be easier to achieve in face-to-face encounters because a person’s body language tends to reveal intrinsic aspects of the state.

As long as a person’s immediate surroundings provide important clues to his social and cultural background a similar point applies when values are communicated. Our personal values, the activities we like to participate in and the complex ways we wish to live our lives, are first and foremost accessible by observations of how we actually choose to live our lives in the contexts we are in. In this sense similarities and differences in values are often easier to detect face-to-face than interactively, and incorrect attributions of values do not occur so easily.

There is a further even more fundamental difference between the fourth and the first three communication conditions. The first three focus on conditions for communication of concept-involving prepositional attitudes like beliefs and thoughts. This means that they are subject to the aim of understanding as a ‘fusion of horizon’, the idea that fundamental understanding is a matter of speaker and audience sharing subjective states involving the same concepts. (Gadamer 1975, 1994; Mueller-Vollmer 1986; Green 2000). A speaker and an audience who share many of the same beliefs have cognitive horizons that are much more similar than communicators who do not have many of the same beliefs. From the perspective of a speaker, the practical implications of this idea that a fusion of horizons should be regarded as an aim of understanding can be formulated as three action-guiding questions: corresponding to the first communication condition (i), does the audience have an understanding of the language I use that is sufficiently similar to my own understanding? Corresponding to the second condition (ii), do I have the genuine attention of the audience? And corresponding to the third (iii), is it reasonable to think that the audience will associate the belief that I express literally in language with other beliefs that are radically different from the beliefs I have?

It is important to recognize that since the fourth condition does not focus on conceptual states a similar question related to the idea of a shared horizon cannot be formulated. An experiential state like pain does not involve concepts that can be shared with another person. Of course, if a person reports ‘I am in pain’, and if an interpreter takes this to mean that the person is in pain, then they share the concept pain. But as emphasized above, this is not the same as sharing the state of pain. Similarly with values; a speaker might appreciate living his life in a certain way and attempt to communicate this value to an audience by using a particular sentence. The audience might associate this sentence with the same concepts as the speaker, but this does not mean that they share the same value. In order to understand what the underlying value is, the audience needs to take a further step and identify the value state that lies beneath the surface of language. A misunderstanding of the fourth kind occurs when this attempt fails. The question a speaker needs to ask in order to prevent misunderstandings of this kind is therefore this: Have I correctly understood the values of my audience, and is there a chance that I will be ascribed values that I do not have? 

This question about values should be sharply distinguished from the question of whether a person expresses a true or false subjective state. A belief is subject to rational discussion about truth and falsity; if someone thinks that a person has a false belief, he can rationally try to show the person that the proposition he believes in is false. Since values are attitudes to activities and not propositions, they are not subject to similar questions about objectivity. If someone wants to influence or change another person’s values, the only rational way of doing so is to go beneath them, to locate possible beliefs and thoughts they are grounded in. For instance, I appreciate drinking a lot of coffee. This is an everyday personal value I have, but I would not have it if I formed the belief that drinking a lot of coffee is very unhealthy. So, if a person I consider to be a medical expert explained to me that me my activity is very unhealthy, then I would probably form this belief, and I would no longer have my value.

It is therefore sometimes possible to change a person’s values by identifying unjustified beliefs that support them. The problem arises only if we think that a person’s values are equivalent to beliefs and thoughts and consequently attempts to show the person that his values are not ‘objectively correct’. A person who is subject to such a criticism will typically feel that we are encroaching on a private sphere that we are not entitled to enter; the person has already an implicit grasp of the nature of personal values as subjective states that we have an individual right to form.

A further discussion of this issue would fall outside the scope of this article, but I think it has been important to make it clear exactly why successful communication presupposes that communicators, implicitly or explicitly, are able to distinguish beliefs and thoughts from personal values. A fundamental identification of a person’s values is often crucial for successful communication, regardless whether or not we want to change these values.

7. Conclusion

By using examples from paramedic-patient interaction within a theoretical framework from philosophy of mind and language, I have tried to explain how the idea of communication conditions can be used to analyze communication. In doing so I have made a distinction between four fundamental conditions. The first focuses on the idea of a shared language, the second on communicative attention, the third on the way we associate beliefs with other beliefs, and the fourth on subjective states like experiences and values that do not have a conceptual, propositional content.

I have argued that these four conditions constitute fundamental communicative aims both face-to-face and in interactive communication. At the same time they suggest different strategies for how these aims should be achieved within the two realms of communication. The fact that the four conditions cover both forms of communication constitutes a fundamental justification for adopting these strategies in face-to-face and interactive interaction. This does not mean that the conditions imply that it is easier to secure successful face-to-face communication than it is to secure interactive communication. Obviously, it is natural to assume that it is often easier to achieve the former than the latter (but there are some obvious exceptions), but the question of whether this really is so remains a further question. My aim has been to develop a plausible framework for addressing this and other normative questions related to face-to-face and interactive communication.

In addition to this instrumental justification for applying the communication conditions, .I think it is important to recognize a further argument. It is sometimes held that an instrumental justification of a theory must be essentially incomplete, since it is possible for an instrumental theory to be false (Dennett 1978). But in this context I do not think this is a genuine possibility. Philosophical theories of communication are after all meant to capture ordinary discourse - it is standardly assumed that whether they do or not is what makes them true or false  - so in this case the fact that the conditions match our communicative practices constitutes a good reason for holding that they are true. Too often philosophical theories of communication are developed in isolation from areas of application, even though it is claimed that they are grounded in common sense. What I have tried to show is that the four communication conditions are really grounded in ordinary communicative practices.

Finally, I would like to make it clear that it has not been possible to discuss in detail the practical consequences of the analyses I have made within the limits of this article. The aim has been to develop and clarify some fundamental philosophical distinctions and to point out some reasonable implications of these distinctions. However, more empirical research is necessary to explore these implications further. What I have offered is a framework for doing such research, but this is a framework that in itself should be modified and developed further on the basis of such research.


Bechtel W. & Graham G. (eds) (1998). A Companion to Cognitive Science. Oxford: Blackwell publishing.
Bezuidenhout A. (1997). ‘The Communication of De Re Thoughts’. NOUS, 31, pp.197-225.
Burge T. (1979). ‘Individualism and the Mental’. Midwest Studies in Philosophy, 4, pp.73-120.
Burge T. (1989). ‘Wherein is Language Social?’, in Reflections on Chomsky, A. George (ed). Oxford: Blackwell.
Cappelen H. & Lepore E. (2005). Insensitive Semantics. Oxford: Blackwell publishing.
Dancy J. (1996) Moral Reasons. Oxford: Blackwell publishing.
Davies M. (1995). ‘Philosophy of Mind’, in Philosophy: A Guide Through the Subject, A.C Grayling (ed). Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Davies M. (1998). ‘Externalism, Architecturalism, and Epistemic Warrant’, in Knowing Our Own Minds, C. Wright, B. Smith and C. Macdonald (eds). Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Davidson D. (1984). Inquires into Truth and Interpretation. Oxford: Clarendon Press.
Davidson D. (1987). ’Knowing One’s Own Mind’, Proceedings of the American Philosophical Association, 61, pp.430-70.
Dennett D. (1978). Consciousness Explained. Middlesex: Penguin Books.
Eide T. & Eide H. (2004). Kommunikasjon i praksis. Oslo: Gyldendal akademisk.
Enelow A., Forde D. & Brummel-Smith K. (1996). Interviewing and Patient Care. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Gadamer H. G. (1975). Truth and Method. New York: Seabury Press.
Gadamer H. G. (1994). Literature and Philosophy in Dialogue. Albany NY: State University of New York Press. 
Green G. (2000). Theology, Hermeneutics, and Imagination: the Crisis of Interpretation at the End of Modernity. Cambridge UK: Cambridge University Press.
Guttenplan S. (ed.) (1996). A Companion to Philosophy of Mind. Oxford: Blackwell publishing.
Johnston P. (1989). Wittgenstein and Moral Philosophy. Oxford: Routledge.
Kripke S. (1982). Wittgenstein on rules and private language. Oxford: Blackwell publishing.
Mechanic D. (1968). Medical Sociology. New York/London: The Free Press.
Mueller-Vollmer K. (ed.) (1986). The Hermeneutics Reader: Texts of the German Tradition from the Enlightenment to the Present. Oxford: Blackwell publishing.
Nettleton S. (1995). The Sociology of Health and Illness. Cambridge UK: Polity Press.
Nordby H. (2004a). ‘The Importance of Knowing How to talk about illness without applying the concept of illness’, Nursing Philosophy, 5, pp.30-40.
Nordby H. (2004b). ‘Communicative Challenges for Paramedics’. Scand J Trauma Resusc Emerg Med,12, pp.178-182.
Nordby H. (2004c). ‘Incorrect Understanding and Concept Possession’, Philosophical Explorations, 7, pp.51-75.
Nordby H. (2006). ‘Nurse-patient-interaction: Language Mastery and Concept Possession’. Nursing Inquiry, 13, pp.64-72.
Peacocke C. (1992). A Study of Concepts Cambridge MA: MIT Press.
Peacocke C. (1998). Being Known. Oxford: Clarendon Press.
Pessin A. & Goldberg S. (eds) (1996). The Twin Earth Chronicles. New York/London: M.E. Sharpe.
Putnam H. (1981). Reason, Truth and History. Cambridge, UK: Cambridge University Press.
Radley A. (1994). Making Sense of Illness. London: Sage publications.
Rosenthal D. (1991). The Nature of Mind. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Ryle G. (1949). The Concept of Mind. London: Huchinson.
Smith N. (1997). Strong Hermeneutics: Contingency and Moral Identity London: Routledge.
Tjora A. (1997). Caring Machines. Dr. Polit Thesis in Sociology. Trondheim: NTNU.
Travelbee J. (1971). Interpersonal Aspects of Nursing Philadelphia: Davis.
Warnke G. (1987). Gadamer: Hermeneutics, Tradition, and Reason. Stanford CA: Stanford University Press.
Wittgenstein, L. (1953). Philosophical Investigations Oxford: Blackwell publishing.
Worhall J. & Worhall J. (2003). ‘Defining Disease: Much Ado about Nothing?’ Analecta Husserliana, 72, pp.33-55.

1 An important motivation for providing information about the patient’s condition is that the paramedics can prepare themselves mentally and in practical terms for the situation that awaits them.
2 It is in general a sound methodological principle that issues of understanding and communication are not subject to questions about normativity in the way questions of truth and knowledge are.
3 I am grateful to an anonymous referee for this journal for pointing out that this objection needs to be addressed.
4 As emphasized above, this can be an understanding that the audience thinks is correct in general but also an understanding that is employed for communicative purposes. The important point is that the understanding that the audience employs must approximate the speaker’s understanding.
5 When the condition of a patient is perceived as not being acute the ambulance is not required to adopt ‘code one’ which is the code for acute situations, and it might take some time before it arrives (but outside central areas it might take some time even if the code is ‘code one’).
6 A meaning explanation is here understood as the explanation a speaker would give if he was asked to explain what a word applies to. Meaning explanations are very seldom conceived of as complete descriptions of what a word means; we do not consider them as sentences that capture the whole meaning of the term we are asked to explain.  They are rather statements that capture central aspects of a word’s meaning. Compare, for instance, the explanation ‘The word ‘dog’ applies to a group of mammals with four legs’ with the explanation ‘ The word ‘dog’ applies to an animal my grandmother has’. Only the first statement is normally conceived of as a meaning explanation.
7 Consider again a doctor who tells a patient that he has not been able to locate any underlying disease. The patient, we might suppose, thinks that he must have a disease, and thinks that the doctor has a very narrow understanding of ‘disease’. An important part of the reason why such an attitude is widespread is that the patient thinks that he is entitled to use ‘disease’ in the way he has learned the word in his special social and cultural context. This point generalizes to countless words with non-standard application conditions.
8 This kind of misunderstanding is sometimes displayed in newspapers, under headlines like
‘The doctor gave me six months to live’. One should be skeptical about the idea that doctors very often state predictions in such a bold way.  In fact, what has often been stated is something much weaker (‘There is a significant possibility that…’), but patients often associate these statements with stronger claims. This is a general phenomenon that most professionals involved in interaction with various forms of clients or patients should be aware of: we tend to forget qualifications like ‘significant possibility’ after a while, and we think of claims that have been made as much stronger than what they in reality were.



Monitor 2011 - The digital state of the Norwegian school

Lillian Gran

Department of Education and Social Work
Lillehammer University College
Email: This email address is being protected from spambots. You need JavaScript enabled to view it.

Review of the national digital survey

A yearly digital survey committed in compulsory school in Norway

Keywords: The Digital condition of the Norwegian compulsory school, motivated students, technology, media, digital natives

Monitor 2011(Egeberg, 2012) is a submission on the fifth quantitative survey of the Norwegian digital health situation completed by Egeberg et al. The survey is a qualified comparison foundation with international surveys on digital competence such as, e.g. PISA. Since 2003, the digital surveys have been completed every other year in Norway to identify indications on schools' digital state. The respondents who were chosen are a selection of school leaders, teachers and student in the 8th and 9th grades and level two in upper secondary school. The submissions research and results are also organized according to these three areas of participants.


Digital Storytelling, Mediatized Stories: Self-Representations in New Media

Knut Lundby (red.)

Publisher: Peter Lang Publishing, New York, 2008.

Reviewed by
Jill Walker Rettberg
Associate Professor of Digital Culture
University of Bergen

We live in an age in which more and more of us are creating our own "digital stories". In 2008, 18% of Norwegian 16-24 year olds were recorded as being active bloggers over the previous three months (Statistics Norway, "ICT in households", 2nd quarter 2008) while more than 2/3 of American teenagers have uploaded self-produced material to the Internet, in the form of YouTube videos, photographs, blogs, stories, remixes etc. (Pew Internet). The numbers of these "user-made" cultural productions are growing year by year and spreading from the younger generation to us adults, who are now the group most increasingly represented on Facebook. In blogs and on Facebook the distinction between amateur and professional is largely meaningless.


Story Circle: Digital Storytelling Around the World.

John Hartley and Kelly McWilliam (eds.)

Publisher: Malden, Mass.: Wiley-Blackwell, 2009

Reviewed by
Birte Hatlehol
PhD student in Media Education
Norwegian University of Science and Technology
Email: This email address is being protected from spambots. You need JavaScript enabled to view it.

The anthology Story Circle is an international study of digital storytelling that discusses the phenomenon in a global context. The book contains 20 articles with contributions from a number of key specialists with wide-ranging experience in the field of DST.


Moving Media Studies - Remediation Revisited

Edited by Heidi Philipsen and Lars Qvortrup

Publisher: Samfundslitteratur Press: Frederiksberg Press, 2007.

Reviewed by
Stephen Dobson
Lillehammer University College
Email: This email address is being protected from spambots. You need JavaScript enabled to view it.
Two questions can be asked: firstly, not do we need another book on remediation, but why? And secondly, if this is the case, what kind of book should it be? This review spirals around these questions.

Global perspectives on E-learning.

Rhetoric and reality by A. A. Carr-Chellman (Ed.). Thousand Oaks, CA: SAGE, 2005

Reviewed by
Dr. J. Ola Lindberg
Department of Education, Mid Sweden University
Email: This email address is being protected from spambots. You need JavaScript enabled to view it.
Dr. Anders D. Olofsson
Department of Education, Umeå University
Email: This email address is being protected from spambots. You need JavaScript enabled to view it.

It seems suitable to begin this review by giving a brief description of the context in which the texts of this book are produced. If it fails to be regarded as a description, then we hope at least it can be regarded as one possible understanding of the context. When contextualizing a book, a good idea seems to be to start with a few words about the editor, Alison A. Carr-Chellman.
buy fosamax online amoxicillin cheapest price mg rosuvastatin sale drug haldol online order bangalore sinemet cheapest price new zealand canadian pharmacy lariam vidal order singulair online india buy sominex free over the counter benadryl for allergic reaction antabuse sales online xenical buy online kaufen buy cheap avodart online uk how can i get fertomid do you ovulate low cost prednisolone tablets remeron online order ashwagandha online cheap leaves order etodolac online canada where can i purchase revatio order lasix lowest price surgery where can i purchase allopurinol get generic sinequan order accutane online forum aciphex buy online canada flovent inhaler discount card order calcium carbonate online powder canada canadian pharmacy lady era buy dapoxetine tablets online india copegus sale qld how can i get baclofen long cheap price on aciphex online buy aristocort cream online generic advair mylan order xeloda online hydrochloride cheapest price on provera questions where to buy kamagra over the counter wholesale generic keppra manufacturers order singulair online us dapoxetine buy online over the counter where to buy digoxin level purchase amantadine injectable where to buy benicar cheapest place imdur online order zara torsemide online order food where can i buy hoodia gordonii how can i get prandin give generic triamterene hctz sinemet next day delivery where can i buy accutane in stores shop zyprexa cheap renagel fachinfo zerit online order food how can i get unisom natural nights last actoplus next day delivery flowers buy aciphex online generic sumycin online order buy benfotiamine tablets how to get hyaluronic acid naturally order periactin pills ceftin order online bupropion lowest price hcl sr where can i purchase zenegra tablets cheapest price on lipitor drop generic depo provera side effects order diflucan jarabe order differin cream where to buy lotrisone online generic saw palmetto plant flomax sale qld can i buy baytril online hyaluronic acid online cheap injections betapace buy online india fertomid cheapest price in india cialis next day delivery xend canadian drug pharmacy viagra where to buy cialis doctor prescription mestinon sale capsules how can i get alesse you take cheap prograf xl cost of prilosec over the counter pletal buy online legal how can i get rosuvastatin found inderal online cheap generic buy arimidex online day delivery pariet lowest price in lebanon where to buy baclofen high where to buy imuran liquid buy atrovent online inderal over the counter substitute dilantin lowest price z1 how can i get prandin does saw palmetto shop generic accutane uk buy amantadine nyc how can i get prandin xanax together where can you buy hoodia pills buy cafergot you how can i get tenormin can you order retin a online where to buy haloperidol uk buy cephalexin 250 mg canada pharmacy arimidex prescription generic topamax janssen where can you buy xenical discount prilosec together where to buy benicar europe cheap topamax in usa generic requip xl where can i purchase shuddha guggulu capsule order topamax online brand name where to buy zyban we lariam buy online hcl buy rocaltrol online low cost actos rooms antabuse sale china periactin cheapest price hydrochloride buy wellbutrin sr 150 order triamterene online bestellen order allopurinol side nootropil online order tracking premarin cheapest price generic buy cheap phenergan medicine buy tetracycline in uk cheap saw palmetto quality celadrin buy online dealers cephalexin online cheap dresses furosemide over the counter where can i buy discount fincar imuran online cheap outlet how can i get eurax cream take to work cheapest price on norvasc retail shop himplasia dosage how can i get claritin juice order acivir cream levlen cheapest price yojimbo where can i purchase tulsi canada order clonidine uk where can i purchase benadryl xanax buy fluoxetine online uk how can i get prandin body buy colchicine from canada buy xeloda online without order anacin online where can i purchase beconase kong caverta online cheap watches digoxin online order can u purchase ampicillin online lukol non prescription kamagra cheapest online where to buy evista korea where to buy sominex manufactured where to buy imuran dublin kamagra online cheap oral jelly uk how can i get tofranil where can i purchase paroxetine find buy zovirax cream canada how can i get fml forte taste how can i get prandin long does how can i get torsemide counter fast shipping cymbalta online canada buy clomid singapore azithromycin over the counter boots buy prazosin online medication buy bactrim online canada order cytoxan online free vpxl cheapest price ebay buy wellbutrin in mexico nolvadex online order kopen discount caravans how can i get toprol blood pressure buy diflucan amazon can you buy advair online buy prandin for cheap where to buy proscar in canada canadian pharmacy zerit test cheap tricor amantadine online cheap uk how can i get paxil zoloft buy cheap ginseng xunta de galicia buy zithromax online australia where to buy cialis in qatar trandate ordering guide how can i get nizoral pronounce etodolac cheapest price uk femara online cheaper version pyridium ordering online shop rental toronto beconase lowest price xbox buy xenical australia danazol ordering numbers buy cephalexin for dogs uk toradol cheapest price walmart how can i get allopurinol fast does it work cytoxan cheapest price hotels how do i take trazodone where can i buy accutane v-drugstore antivert buy online can you where to buy famvir ebay carafate cheapest price hcl wholesale generic celebrex from canada digoxin generic for lanoxin venlor xr generic sinemet cheapest price nz singulair non perscription or cheapest price on diarex himalaya buy cheap proventil singapore canadian pharmacy advair hfa canadian pharmacy roxithromycin dosage order differin gel online is premarin available over the counter wholesale generic celebrex substitute lopressor buy online can you cheapest price on avapro hct mevacor online order number diakof ordering numbers order citalopram online get where to buy requip at walmart where to buy albendazole vietnam how can i get tenormin help reduce hypertension buy amantadine at walmart low cost part d cheap saw palmetto drug interactions combivent sale uk wholesale generic dramamine youtube cheapest price on zyloprim gout buy cheap feldene high carafate cheapest price jeans risperdal cheapest price quicklet 2mg effexor lowest price africa how can i get rocaltrol cost with insurance wholesale generic celebrex good cheapest price on chloramphenicol philippines where to buy hcg and nolvadex liv 52 sale liver cleanse order vasotec dosage generic for oxybutynin carafate cheapest price suspension mircette cheapest price melbourne cheapest price on rogaine bangalore order mestinon online australia where to buy calcium carbonate powder wholesale generic omnicef cost buy benfotiamine zealand buy xenical online uk maxalt online cheap in usa how can i get detrol much inderal online order mg buy zero skateboards buy lynoral tablet bactroban online order hyderabad buy baclofen uk where can i purchase cozaar prescription where can i purchase tulsi grow coumadin sale xbox saw palmetto online cheap mumbai shop rental in singapore purchase orlistat dogs where to buy cefadroxil tablet purchase clomid jasper lady era online cheap outlet buy viagra online with a mastercard clindamycin over the counter equivalent cheap shuddha guggulu malaysia order finpecia online pharmacy canadian pharmacy toprol fatigue buy cheap viramune boots shop saw palmetto and hair loss canadian pharmacy lopid work how can i get diltiazem u use skelaxin buy online india buspar for sale aceon over the counter you buy buy finax online pharmacy discount prinivil program generic lariam hcl buy detrol online overnight delivery glimepiride generic drug generic vasotec uses where can i purchase omnicef canada where to buy sominex us doxycycline online order rx canadian pharmacy wellbutrin online buy flovent hfa 44 mcg cheap shuddha guggulu uk how can i get diltiazem before how can i get ginseng root worth finpecia buy online how can i get tenormin to stop taking over the counter benadryl for itching generic xeloda vidal rocaltrol non perscription eyeglasses imitrex generic date generic amoxil hydrochloride zantac order online buy premarin brisbane how can i get claritin xanax where to buy proscar brand buy renagel nyc order lamictal online pharmacy eurax non perscription sunglasses where to buy cefadroxil nz aceon cheapest price canada cheap nexium tablets where can i purchase benfotiamine nature canada pharmacy lipitor sante' low cost bentyl for fosamax buy online want cheap femara version atrovent online cheap uk how can i get hytrin stay in your system buy calcitriol injection ventolin hfa sale keppra next day delivery times where to buy triamterene real colchicine cheapest price jumperoo low cost programs for troubled youth zovirax online order tablets buy zyprexa online canada generic amoxil liquid generic viagra canada pharmacy where can i buy cheap advair discount zyban kullan?m? where can i purchase carafate vancouver stromectol online order apteka discount retin a xcode apply avapro over the counter drugs like buy amoxicillin online ireland buy cheap copegus a prescription order citalopram online uk where to buy casodex uses lamictal online cheap usa cheap betnovate ointment methotrexate online order hyderabad buy cheap cleocin t gel online how can i get rosuvastatin use where can i purchase motilium jarabe endep generic order diflucan online mg buy glucotrol online buy remeron where can i buy xenical egypt buy mentat quotes generic clozaril generic canadian pharmacy viagra cost cheaper price on singulair version myambutol non perscription xanex clomid online cheap venda where can i buy motilium the counter in uk order voltaren xr betnovate cheapest price melbourne where to buy digoxin side cheap price on rogaine in canada how can i get floxin otic cost generic celexa zinc undecylenate discount zofran dosage is generic femara effective buy amoxicillin trihydrate online buy arimidex online fast shipping differin online order cream how can i get tenormin much does zantac lowest price z10 buy mentats online dapoxetine buy online generic viagra buy online in uk mentax cheapest price canadian pharmacy styplon benefits how can i get lipitor joint pain buy liv 52 online gratis generic name for dulcolax low cost glucotrol dosage cheap kamagra deals uk where to buy abayas online wholesale generic plavix target fosamax buy online in usa aygestin non perscription buy generic diovan hct online coumadin sale australia buy calcium hydrogen carbonate cheap shatavari root order calcium carbonate online hydrochloric acid order nolvadex online ko"pa purchase voltaren gel online generic digoxin just as good where can i purchase clonidine apply cheapest price on tamoxifen philippines benzac cheapest price php nizoral cheapest price cream wholesale generic nicotinell patches abana buy online india inderal online order canada where to buy methotrexate store cheap abayas from china buy antabuse in the uk cheap rogaine.com cheapest price on tulsi extrusions shop cafergot generic buy alavert the counter generic apcalis gel order clonidine legal cheap robaxin high shop rental prices ciprofloxacin cheapest price dpco buy lynoral indikasi furosemide over the counter has where can i purchase synthroid liquid buspar sale nz canadian pharmacy indocin reviews buy moduretic lek shallaki lowest price india combivent sale xbox order etodolac reviews order triamterene online fast shipping buy nexium online canada pharmacy meclizine hydrochloride cheapest price on claritin vs how can i get propranolol just stop fast shipping prednisone online overnight how much can lipitor reduce cholesterol generic femara hcl buy keflex online australia over the counter similar to prilosec buy cheap pariet generic lariam photo epivir-hbv cheapest price list cheap saw palmetto topical where to buy nolvadex forum cheap metformin in usa adalat non perscription diuretic how can i get allegra hives diakof ordering guide how can i get aspirin x 1024 atoms of carbon carafate next day delivery flowers shop zyprexa xanax buy cheap adalat episode torsemide online order uk generic viagra mexico pharmacy keppra online cheap shopping discount retin a on neck allegra d online order where to buy motilium uk canadian pharmacy remeron zyprexa cheapest price generic where to buy benicar rx buy celebrex online uk wholesale generic antabuse price diakof ordering hydrochlorothiazide buy online united states liv 52 ordering medicine low cost prednisolone dosage canadian pharmacy wellbutrin northwest nolvadex cheapest price in delhi buy cheap saw palmetto republic of macedonia where can i purchase zithromax vidal generic celexa vs lexapro buy singulair 10 mg cheapest price on lipitor pakistan singulair non perscription contacts levlen cheapest price hotels discount retin a gel purchase dostinex you differin online order apteka lamictal buy online where to buy indinavir from canada canadian pharmacy zerit abilify non perscription formulary or non-formulary canadian pharmacy nizoral 2 shop celadrin on line order serpina online menu vpxl online cheap flights cheap price on lopid online buy zyprexa skelaxin online cheaper alternative order altace a prescription where to buy imitrex a prescription celexa side effects eye twitching benicar online order hct avodart online order sale cheapest price on cystone in uae buy micronase place where to buy cytoxan melbourne motrin cheapest price uk buy aciphex online sale buy benfotiamine australia order calendar online india flovent lowest price walgreens does generic topamax work for weight loss generic amoxil vs imitrex online order buy renagel valor where to buy indinavir excreted zetia lowest price z10 where to buy dilantin australia abilify non perscription diuretic where to buy triamterene sell order cytotec online generic amantadine difference between remeron canadian pharmacy viagra canadian pharmacy vipps approved buy colchicine singapore buy singulair 4mg chewable buy rocaltrol uses where can i purchase allopurinol hydrochloride canadian pharmacy remeron online where to buy danazol over the counter where can i purchase luvox online order triamterene online safely crestor get you high purchase lipotropic injections buy lopressor epivir-hbv non perscription viagra canadian pharmacy trental prices keppra online cheap bestellen how can i get astelin you take inderal online order tracking order clonidine australia panmycin online cheap uk bentyl cheapest price hotels generic amantadine insurance low cost part-time business opportunities amoxicillin online cheap from canada zovirax online order zumiez cheap renagel low cost actos medical insurance generic viagra in the usa finpecia buy online espan~a where to buy artane online australia where can i purchase cozaar work in the body cheapest price on abilify uk buy cephalexin side imuran over the counter drugs like buy fluoxetine hong kong clomid lowest price drug saw palmetto sale reviews fast shipping famvir online australia purchase chloramphenicol pyridium buy online uk cheap benemid where to buy eldepryl over the counter flagyl over the counter drug buy altace africa generic diabecon ingredients buy vermox suspension generic saw palmetto acne finax cheapest price in india buy clomid from india where to buy omnicef online buy elimite online olanzapine online cheap australia baclofen over the counter spain coumadin order set where can i buy hoodia diet pills inderal online cheap can you canadian pharmacy lady era review lotrisone buy online generic wholesale generic zerit taxi mevacor online order alli online cheap gu"nstig where to buy famvir bulk generic etodolac vs where can i purchase zyprexa nz low cost actos tablet where to buy raloxifene uk buy v gel ingredients order cytotec online kaufen order beconase online us lisinopril buy online buy bupropion 100 mg buy crestor in uk where to buy sominex chloramphenicol online cheap eye drops generic xenical just as good cheapest price on etodolac in usa order mestinon online in usa copegus sale the uk buy cipro online colchicine cheapest price sigma liv 52 sale estrogen discount calan west flagler street miami fl how can i get astelin quickly does buy cheap lamisil where can i purchase sarafem do sumycin cheapest price jeans risperdal cheapest price india buy dostinex domestic buy pletal online day delivery how can i get prandin generic adalat non perscription uk viagra online canadian pharmacy reviews minocycline generic target how can i get allopurinol much depakote lowest price costco cheap rogaine foam canada how can i get fertomid fast does order etodolac prescription generic saw palmetto kroger where to buy bupropion sr 150 mg where can i purchase revatio new york buy penegra online india aleve over the counter buy accutane online reviews wholesale generic plavix yet xeloda online cheap for sale pyridium buy online in canada stromectol online order apotheke where to buy benicar bula order unisom a prescription xeloda buy online ireland lady era ordering bulimica cheapest price on antabuse list buy shatavari online cheapest price on antabuse online buy betnovate skin cream lioresal non perscription diuretic buy amitriptyline 10mg online canadian pharmacy trental for viagra order mestinon online legal buy cheap suprax baru where to buy suprax liquid wholesale generic cardura farmaco how can i get benfotiamine home canadian pharmacy trental pet meds when did motrin go over the counter purchase uroxatral experience where can i purchase zetia in toronto where to buy haldol cheapest price on albenza effectiveness cyklokapron ordering numbers nolvadex online order research cefadroxil online order tracking generic brand of avapro retin-a next day delivery times prazosin lowest price xbox cheapest price on naprosyn australia canada pharmacy remeron sante' how can i get lipothin natural cleanse buy cheap shallaki benefits purchase pletal a prescription where can i buy xenical vgb generic coumadin pictures buy mestinon online getting order voltaren online bestellen mycelex-g non perscription lenses mestinon buy online drug rosuvastatin sale malaysia seroflo cheapest price website where can i buy femara-letrozole how can i get bupropion is working order cytotec online quiero comprar propecia cheapest price dubai buy cheap colchicine zealand buy slimex online uk precose cheapest price no insurance where to buy protonix work buy plavix you where can i purchase cozaar in toronto maxalt online cheap india where can i buy beconase aqueous nasal spray buy cheap cleocin usa bought keppra online has anyone where to buying exelon fitzpatrick buy antabuse you order clonidine dosage how do i make aspirin paste famvir online order zara where to buy sominex ebay clozaril generic name cheapest price on zetia best lopid non perscription inhaler where to buy minocycline you aspirin online cheap xbox order anacin online nz purchase singulair you buy dostinex how can i get alesse using colchicine online cheap dresses benemid buy online where to buy chloramphenicol work altace next day delivery time olanzapine non perscription retin-a buy online uk cheap saw palmetto hair loss speman cheapest price melbourne femara online cheap pharmacy buy lisinopril hctz 20 12.5 mg wholesale generic augmentin mg cheapest price on flovent software kamagra lowest price africa generic prevacid not working wholesale generic silagra australia famvir online order you avana cheapest price canada how can i get lamisil for toenail fungus biaxin sale qld dulcolax online cheap order canadian pharmacy viagra legitimate cheap diabecon benefits discount chloroquine uses arimidex online order offers buy cheap phenergan in uk where to buy baclofen do you how can i get ginseng jelly plavix non perscription walmart generic amoxil hcl singulair non perscription alternative where to buy abana wholesale generic benicar when will ginseng online order uk where to buy strattera ranitidine buy online babies generic triamterene mylan buy cheap dulcolax tablets online stromectol online order prescription buy zofran qt buy cheap flagyl dogs phenergan non perscription drowsy purchase singulair hydrochloride discount glucotrol dosage how can i get astelin spray cost generic saw palmetto pcos etodolac over the counter best canadian pharmacy trental king reviews where to buy bupropion cheapest place cheapest price on claritin non drowsy buy lozol indications cabgolin ordering canada cytotec for sale in qatar inderal lowest price xbox procardia ordering buy cheap albendazole zealand how can i get flagyl help diverticulitis discount purim wiki periactin lowest price z10 low cost capoten uses lipitor next day delivery nyc how can i get diltiazem after taking buy benadryl online dye free arava online order return buy cheap lanoxin uses order flagyl by mail discount fincar ltda artane castle photoshop cheapest price on neurontin retail buy prazosin online delivery allopurinol buy online sale liv 52 sale is good for liver buy cheap carafate nausea buy diflucan online india generic lariam vs how can i get slimex virkning dilantin lowest price xperia buy benadryl online tablets medrol lowest price z10 singulair non perscription medicinal ingredients kamagra lowest price in malaysia actoplus next day delivery quote clonidine buy online rx oxytrol online cheap order avodart cheapest price hair loss zantac lowest price uk sinemet cheapest price hotels mestinon online order tracking doxycycline online order zumiez wholesale generic plavix effient discount retin a xanthelasma cheapest price on naprosyn high betapace buy online generic topamax cost rhinocort online cheap pharmacy where to buy imuran without insurance generic for dramamine buy cheap copegus alternative lexapro buy online for sale bought aciphex online has anyone neurontin non perscription drugs mircette non perscription uk buy cheap feldene uk wholesale generic fosamax name periactin buy online dogs medrol lowest prices generic lariam buy online us how can i get ditropan stop how can i get prandin zolpidem ventolin sale buy cheap diovan bula where can i purchase cleocin powder buy hydrochlorothiazide in thailand wholesale generic toradol for toradol buy unisom online kaufen cheapest price on ashwagandha tonic discount minomycin work cheap price on flovent canada order flonase australia how can i get alesse much does it cost buy cipro online application wholesale generic augmentin effects buy nootropil canada order finpecia online farmacia how to get through paxil withdrawal allopurinol next day delivery uk ginseng cheapest price capsules gasex lowest price laptop how can i get arava much does liv 52 sale syrup price order adalat online hindi serial order cytotec online quero comprar generic saw palmetto dht blocker wholesale generic bupropion does buy speman online forte buy micronase us order toradol online getting inderal online order offer buy calcium carbonate msds where can i buy lipitor korea cheap evecare review how can you get lithium alesse next day delivery uk wholesale generic claritin while pregnant ginseng cheapest price buying generic accutane brands where can i purchase dilantin metabolized how can i get bentyl quickly does cheapest price on norvasc without insurance erection pills over the counter uk buy rogaine foam buy cheap phenergan can you generic celexa pill identifier generic viagra when rhinocort cheapest price kindle albendazole next day delivery quote revatio buy online india risperdal cheapest price africa griseofulvin over the counter buy cheap price on beconase very generic arimidex side effects buy diflucan uk buy inderal online canada how can i get fertomid stay in your system buy cafergot brisbane nimotop next day delivery haldol next day delivery flowers buy cabergoline online clonidine over the counter has vermox buy usa periactin cheapest price way glucophage cheapest price jeans wholesale generic claritin not working buy zithromax online next day delivery low cost bactroban zalf how can i get danazol for angioedema promethazine buy online from canada cipro lowest price generic form of avodart order azulfidine online in usa lariam buy online a prescription cheapest price on xeloda kg how can i get ginseng to take where to buy lipitor generic where can i purchase provera kredita discount retin a long term side effects purchase amantadine line where can you buy motilium oxybutynin buy online how can i get benfotiamine to take cheapest price on beconase nasal spray flonase buy uk wholesale generic bupropion mg buy vermox plus celadrin buy online products buy precose online next day delivery wholesale generic plavix cost canadian pharmacy artane tesco where to buy mobic liquid buy flagyl online ireland how can i get ginseng per day hyaluronic acid online cheap nz can you buy clomid online uk buy azulfidine online sale discount retin a neutrogena where to buy astelin purchase orlistat hexal generic imitrex walmart where to buy valtrex korea buy celebrex zamiennik mestinon buy online coupons mestinon buy online hydrochloride digoxin online order offer buy precose online mexico lipotrexate non perscription xanax buy cheap copegus veterinary buy name brand wellbutrin where to buy calcium carbonate chalk how imuran works buy calcium carbonate online for pools over the counter substitute for flomax buy precose online bestellen wholesale generic hydrochlorothiazide for diovan where to buy valtrex day delivery where to buy haldol generic alli online cheap piller buy azulfidine online epocrates voltaren cream over the counter prilosec liquid over the counter buy lasix injection cheapest price on zyvox canada where to buy plavix ginseng get high methotrexate sale cheapest price on lioresal pakistan how can i get diltiazem normal where to buy oxytrol over the counter buy amantadine real buy pletal online fast shipping anafranil online order india buy cheap albendazole can buy premarin edmonton buy cheap cyklokapron uk precose cheapest price india generic lariam brand xeloda buy online us low cost betapace manufacturer buy generic periactin wholesale generic himcocid himalaya how can i get unisom every night while pregnant isoptin online cheap designer alli online cheap weight loss pills buy precose online from uk copegus sale in canada canadian pharmacy cyklokapron dose wholesale generic keppra cost walmart generic viagra prices actos over the counter medicine for uti how can i get benfotiamine to work clarithromycin generic philippines buy toradol online without low cost zebeta how can i get diltiazem help angina canadian pharmacy nexium people;s buy premarin online ordering buy lisinopril in uk how can i get lipothin stop how can i get fertomid drink how can i get arava xr where to buy sominex do you depakote lowest price mg canadian pharmacy phexin uses canadian pharmacy remeron uses femara generic name amoxicillin buy online generic where can i purchase benfotiamine do valtrex cheapest price at walmart carafate cheapest price generic order adalat online hindi full movie slimex buy online bestellen generic flagyl side effects generic triamterene difference between shop cafergot singapore where to buy eldepryl do you where to buy cheap colchicine aceon over the counter can you get clomid online cheap sale generic for topamax tablets buy cheap bonnispaz how can i get torsemide take low cost hytrin medication wholesale generic metoclopramide hydrochloride fosamax buy online real wholesale generic hydrochlorothiazide brand name cheapest price on antabuse india where can i purchase zestril where to buy mobic line purchase apcalis avis buy betnovate n cream cheapest price on pletal list rogaine sale coupon buy colchicine south africa periactin over the counter zofran sale qld buy unisom online forums buy minocycline online canada premarin cheapest price kindle order etodolac online usa how can i get tofranil be discontinued how can i get celadrin pregnant generic wellbutrin side effects compare accutane prices cheap wellbutrin online cheap alternative for nexium buy flovent hfa online buy detrol online delivery where can i purchase shuddha guggulu ingredients dilantin online cheap kurti buy proventil inhaler online order clonidine side order premarin cream online discount urispas uses tetracycline lowest price acne seroquel online order a prescription etodolac over the counter where can i buy where to buy chloromycetin the counter cheapest price on etodolac nz buy detrol online nz wholesale generic keppra coupon cheapest price on vantin list cheapest price on singulair costco digoxin online order hyderabad buy benadryl online skin allergy relief cream buy zovirax vancouver wholesale generic saw palmetto ymca how can i get fml forte drops canadian pharmacy wellbutrin generic where to buy benicar bangkok order silagra work where can i buy ranitidine syrup order inderal online india rocaltrol non perscription uk vasotec online cheap over the counter replacement for premarin wholesale generic fosamax dosage generic vasotec iv where can i purchase medrol solu buspar sale mexico generic digoxin ingredients mestinon buy online fast delivery generic saw palmetto vitamin where can i buy clonidine japan where can i purchase lipothin buying retin a in mexico where to buy imuran ebay clomid lowest price serophene canadian pharmacy ceftin torsemide online order tracking ralista online order hyderabad how can i get zoloft viibryd buy cheap proventil prescription how can i get claritin should you take where to buy pamelor prescription wholesale generic claritin tablets buy cheap saw palmetto knoxville sumycin cheapest price melbourne epivir-hbv cheapest price website vytorin online order offer is astelin available over the counter liv 52 ordering reviews buy accutane online india cheap forzest review how can i get grifulvin to make where to buy casodex mexico propecia cheapest price propak differin online order hyderabad where to buy tadacip rosuvastatin sale nz order diltiazem india where to buy imitrex at walmart buy doxazosin online zealand ditropan buy online bestellen imitrex buy online india where to buy casodex liquid shop rental denver buy cheap tadalis sx buy calcium carbonate tablets how can i get eldepryl soon does buy hydrochlorothiazide kong canada pharmacy remeron cost wholesale generic augmentin available cipro lowest price z1 nolvadex cheapest price nz how to order diflucan online buy diflucan online cheap wholesale generic benicar effects saw palmetto sale urdu name adalat online order narendra modi cheapest price on xeloda street effexor xr discount coupons retin-a next day delivery gifts epivir-hbv non prescription where to buy clomid over the counter order paxil cr generic micronase price glycomet online cheap shopping discount for atorvastatin torsemide online cheap shopping order differin reviews is albendazole over the counter in usa buy cheap colchicine jicht prilosec over the counter side effects cheapest price on claritin d at walmart buy geriforte dosage low cost pyridium valor rocaltrol non perscription walmart imitrex generic vs. brand propecia over the counter order singulair online purchase where can i buy femara tablets buy remeron vegas nolvadex cheapest price yojimbo how can i get astelin often do you use inderal lowest priced periactin cheapest price retail buy celebrex online australia order tetracycline online get buy keppra online cheap florinef over the counter bought where to buy eldepryl usa buy mentat online free canada pharmacy lexapro buy duphalac non perscription drugs generic triamterene online ventolin online order kopen lariam buy online safely avana lowest price z1 canadian pharmacy penegra price canadian pharmacy nizoral guardian generic prevacid vs prevacid fml forte ordering pink eye wholesale generic hytrin obat discount fincar uk advair vs generic oxytrol online cheap shopping buy cheap viagra sydney shop glucophage xr buy calcium carbonate online for paint finax cheapest price where generic periactin south africa generic imitrex high ciprofloxacin cheapest price material buy calcium carbonate gas cheapest price on tamoxifen in the philippines arava online order pills how can i get allopurinol supplied buy detrol online states purchase motilium jarabe how can i get toprol go off how can i get imuran for ulcerative colitis purchase glucotrol generic how can i get nizoral you take order beconase online overnight delivery buy allegra online episodes chloroquine over the counter sold buy calcium carbonate online supplement mentat online cheap lotrisone buy online ordering advair generic release discount retin a questions order dipyridamole australia where to buy cytoxan bulk prazosin next day delivery times where to buy proscar dr reddys safe non prescription viagra buy xeloda online nz cipro online order zara order anacin online uk how can i get haldol to work lariam buy online powder how often can i take ditropan bupropion low price blood sugar haldol cheapest price finder where can i purchase beconase liquid order finpecia online acquistare where can i purchase zithromax stores where to buy famvir gel shop saw palmetto receding hairline buy amaryl 3mg chloramphenicol to buy order calcium carbonate online where do you betapace buy online prescription actos generic manufacturer where to buy digoxin work in the body low cost synthroid dosage buy zithromax online in australia how can i get paxil night sweats torsemide next day delivery time buy chloramphenicol in europe generic amoxil list amitriptyline non perscription inhaler ventolin lowest price in uk buy propecia cheap online uk canadian pharmacy trental windsor order penegra medicine nolvadex online order get how long can i take lamisil adalat online order liv wholesale generic combivent equivalent where to buy sominex founded buy non prescription viagra uk buy cheap lynoral uk asda ventolin sale keppra over the counter drug amoxil cheapest price canadian pharmacy trental testosterone order hyzaar buy aciclovir australia buy cheap singulair junior canadian pharmacy zyloprim generico methotrexate buy online motrin cheapest price ebay amoxicillin online cheap generic order precose online kopen zovirax online order buying how can i get danazol much does shop antivert high propecia cheapest price in malaysia generic enalapril dogs where to buy artane you precose lowest price z10 discount retin a youtube ayurslim ordering numbers buy cheap plavix valtrex price comparison rhinocort cheapest price hotels tetracycline lowest price in pakistan liv 52 sale nausea actos over the counter yeast infection where to buy cheap clomid online buy cheap antabuse nz how can i get trazodone to die cheap clarina limerick buy lexapro online ireland buy calcium carbonate dosage fucidin lowest price tablets trazodone cheapest price online motrin cheapest price nz where to buy artane dublin cheap generic propecia uk generic dutas online wholesale generic nolvadex sale buy azulfidine veterinary order etodolac high glycomet online cheap clothes where to buy cytotec in johor bahru cheap precose australia revatio buy online vermox cheapest price retail singulair buy online baby msd buy cheap fincar tablet where to buy cardura australia purchase zocor canada how can i get detrol vision wholesale generic keppra safe where to buy evista real where can i purchase xeloda cheap ventolin lowest price puffer kamagra shop deutschland erfahrungen canadian pharmacy tinidazole tablets buy unisom online legal order pletal online a prescription kamagra online cheap london wholesale generic bupropion mylan how can i get zaditor long before it works where can i buy benicar generic where to buy albendazole cheap vpxl cheapest price list periactin online order weight gain cheapest price on provera mercury drug where to buy triamterene kuala lumpur nizoral cheapest price tablet cheap sarafem buy buy unisom online legit hyaluronic acid online cheap low molecular weight where can i buy xenical from zestril lowest price xbox lady era ordering ukmix fucidin lowest price ointment cheapest price on brahmi vati how can i get rosuvastatin video purchase cozaar for dogs mircette cheapest price jeans mircette non perscription diuretic aspirin online cheap outlet where to buy indinavir work lipitor next day delivery xend where to buy benicar york where can i purchase voltaren use shop rental buy calcium carbonate tums wholesale generic indocin name how can i get haldol pronounce atrovent non perscription rhinitis where can i purchase carafate get canadian pharmacy lipitor eagle lamictal online cheap designer wholesale generic calcium carbonate vegan reglan non perscription xanax buy cheap mircette tablets amantadine online cheap australia order deltasone mail luvox online cheap watches aceon cheapest price list discount penegra india where to buy cytoxan london shop saw palmetto for pcos buy dapoxetine priligy online where can i purchase risperdal vancouver shop orlistat bula buy xenical online nz cheapest price on aldactone list cipro low price vacanze buy cheap colchicine purchase amantadine in canada wholesale generic benicar hct be available stromectol online order scabies how can i get nizoral purchase where to buy zofran prescription bactrim cheapest price hotels wholesale generic claritin pictures imuran over the counter pills cheapest price on keftab flomax sale line buy cardizem online mircette buy online birth control where to buy xenical nz where to buy flagyl online cheapest price on norvasc philippines where to buy valtrex legal minocycline for cheap buy cafergot online discount florinef sale xbox shop cafergot paris sumycin online cheap clothes where to buy bupropion pure how can i get celadrin expired speman cheapest price kindle xeloda buy online medication biaxin buy online generic seroflo rotacaps cheapest price on provera jmbg tadacip ordering numbers how can i get propranolol does mentat online cheap kurti indocin next day delivery uk where can i purchase zetia you where to buy eldepryl in uk low cost programmable logic controller how can i get tenormin to take cheapest price on robaxin per pill how can i get paxil viibryd dilantin lowest price cvs where to buy famvir store pariet online cheap australia canadian pharmacy hytrin uses cheapest price on xeloda much generic actos release date where to buy triamterene reviews periactin online order australia purchase pristiq online cheapest price on flovent street buy ginseng how can i get arava pregnant buy haloperidol online ordering zyprexa online cheapest price on ciprofloxacin pakistan order finpecia online order ventolin lowest price australia where to buy digoxin jacc cheap nicotine patches low cost actos holidays generic amantadine as good how can i get serpina finpecia buy online apotheke buy doxazosin online kaufen order ditropan cheapest price on xeloda egypt how can i get propranolol xanax voltaren gel over the counter voltaren tablets over the counter australia how can i get unisom u take cytoxan cheapest price australia buy himalaya diabecon online cheapest price on ashwagandha lehyam order clozaril online australia betnovate sale risperdal cheapest price uk how long after zoloft can i get pregnant where can i buy femara my dog where to buy benicar pharmacy stromectol online order over the counter betapace non perscription glasses how can i get allopurinol long hoodia cheapest price ebay how can i get grifulvin v to work skelaxin over the counter strike albendazole over the counter replacement beconase sale qld where to buy bupropion xl 150 mg how much can i get for a pound of ginseng etodolac cheapest price pills buy doxazosin online paypal finast next day delivery gifts buy rocaltrol generic discount dipyridamole dose order anacin online sale flomax over the counter have cialis next day delivery does serophene over the counter quinn wholesale generic flagyl cvs ventolin inhaler for sale online generic to celexa where can i purchase cleocin pure wholesale generic claritin kirkland buy inderal online paypal where to buy bupropion vancouver buy cheap diovan valsartan shop rhinocort reviews shop glycomet drug colchicine online cheap generic wholesale generic combivent going propecia lowest price buy mestinon online zealand how can i get lipothin to cancel reglan non perscription insulin viagra online order europe clarina cheapest price cream where to buy cialis in kuala lumpur shop renagel bula where to buy femara in canada when did generic accutane become available generic cialis tadacip wholesale generic plavix tablets how can i get bentyl coumadin benzaclin discount coupons glycomet online order usa how to order zithromax online order ditropan jarabe aceon non perscription uk cheapest price on cleocin generic order v gel online lyte v og buy baclofen in australia how long can i take propranolol order cytotec online kopen antivert buy online buy tetracycline line buy aciphex online us order percocet online legally periactin buy online day delivery purchase mircette ingredients viagra online order prescription furosemide low price gfr order atarax online usa where can i purchase cozaar does xeloda buy online mastercard how can i get bentyl pregnant liv 52 ordering vs milk thistle desyrel non perscription inhaler buy toradol online real order penegra uses buy premarin japan precose cheapest price malaysia buy eurax cream australia skelaxin online cheap mexico buy cheap ethionamide usa buy rocaltrol singapore order atarax online wholesale generic benicar alternatives order calan online template where to buy cialis in johor bahru abilify non perscription trova cheap atorlip how can i get rosuvastatin does crestor where to buy ropinirole where to buy cytotec online in the philippines buy generic coumadin how can i get flagyl valtrex cheap precose alternatives buy topamax in canada wholesale generic cystone syrup how can i get lamisil needed accutane cheapest price in india low cost nimotop where to buy chloramphenicol made low cost advair yellow nizoral cheapest price drug unisom next day delivery cause how can i get diltiazem excreted buy cheap mentat forum amantadine online cheap sale cheapest price on adalat zaandam phexin lowest price xperia kamagra the shop buy cheap benzac online buy tadalis where to buy suprax africa where to buy bactrim ds cheapest price on micardis increase cheapest price on diclofenac the philippines ditropan generic name nootropil non perscription walmart aciphex non perscription walmart tetracycline lowest price yojimbo aceon non perscription insulin generic wellbutrin fda low cost kamagra yorumlar? generic of arimidex propranolol sale nz buy detrol online mastercard order triamterene online united states canadian pharmacy nizoral lloyds salep pilex himalaya buy clomid online safely discount prandin tablets buy trimox classification how can i get dianabol discount benfotiamine generic apcalis review ordering zoloft online cheap shuddha guggulu reviews fml forte ordering suspension purchase septilin beneficios wholesale generic altace side effects wholesale generic celebrex side effects how can i get elimite for head lice cheap rogaine quincy aspirin online cheap dresses apcalis online order uk discount antivert high digoxin ordering guide how can i get rosuvastatin long to take buy zyprexa online epocrates lady era ordering jane xeloda buy online paypal cheapest price on rogaine philippines mestinon sale in canada generic for tamoxifen periactin online order illegal canadian pharmacy lady era opinie atrovent online cheap clothes liv 52 sale effects buy chloramphenicol zealand how can i get benfotiamine extract shop feldene gel purchase ciprofloxacin where can i buy accutane virginia sumycin cheapest price website where can i buy femara prescription buy robaxin japan zyloprim online order offers dapoxetine buy online store buy pletal online pharmacy diltiazem buy online uk sinemet cheapest price range trazodone cheapest price insurance remeron online cheap buying kamagra shop gutschein generic actos news buy celebrex side order zenegra online beconase sale usa zofran cheapest price oral zetia lowest price at cvs how can i get claritin cost buy maxalt japan how can i get zoloft gain weight buy entocort online benicar online order zara canadian pharmacy nizoral online lopid next day delivery gifts order azulfidine online best place wholesale generic indocin medication actos over the counter valtrex luvox over the counter i buy orlistat online purchase zenit photo camera buy norvasc sale wholesale generic keppra price order xeloda online next day delivery zetia lowest price generic endep next day delivery quote where to buy indocin zonguldak mevacor cheapest price melbourne shop rental ottawa low cost septilin jarabe buy diflucan fluconazole duphalac non perscription eyeglasses how can i get benfotiamine clean combivent generic available mentax cheapest price prescription diltiazem buy online usa how can i get torsemide given how can i get unisom use cheapest price on micardis walmart order zestril wiki order altace generic prednisolone for sale uk buy aciphex online mexico buy hyaluronic acid injections online buy v gel battery how can i get diltiazem gel how can i get hytrin to take ginseng cheapest price gold buy cheap cleocin gel buy prilosec bulk mentax cheapest price retail wholesale generic plavix picture cheap evecare dosage prilosec sold over the counter bought azulfidine online has anyone cheapest price on cardura obat buy detrol online australia acyclovir over the counter australia liv 52 sale weight gain propranolol sale capsules